Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Fantasy, Counter-fantasy, and Meta-fantasy in Hobbes’s and Butler’s Accounts of Vulnerability

View through CrossRef
Hobbes and Butler both conjure images of an abandoned infant in their respective discussions of vulnerability. Leviathan uses this image to discuss original dominion, or natural maternal right over the child, while for Butler rights discourse produces fantasies of invulnerability that derealize other lives. However, Hobbes’s infant in nature has no rights and can only consent to being nourished. Only when able to nourish itself can it claim rights to transfer through the covenant producing a fantasy of individual invulnerability. Vulnerability in the state of nature and the commonwealth’s fantasy of invulnerability are together a counter-fantasy to the fantasies of invulnerability of Hobbes’s time, through heaven or eternal glory. In question is whether Butler, in her reimagining of community, is, like Hobbes, producing a fantasy, but a meta-fantasy that community can be taken as fantasy without derealizing the fantastic or that fantasizes an honesty about its being fantasy.
Philosophy Documentation Center
Title: Fantasy, Counter-fantasy, and Meta-fantasy in Hobbes’s and Butler’s Accounts of Vulnerability
Description:
Hobbes and Butler both conjure images of an abandoned infant in their respective discussions of vulnerability.
Leviathan uses this image to discuss original dominion, or natural maternal right over the child, while for Butler rights discourse produces fantasies of invulnerability that derealize other lives.
However, Hobbes’s infant in nature has no rights and can only consent to being nourished.
Only when able to nourish itself can it claim rights to transfer through the covenant producing a fantasy of individual invulnerability.
Vulnerability in the state of nature and the commonwealth’s fantasy of invulnerability are together a counter-fantasy to the fantasies of invulnerability of Hobbes’s time, through heaven or eternal glory.
In question is whether Butler, in her reimagining of community, is, like Hobbes, producing a fantasy, but a meta-fantasy that community can be taken as fantasy without derealizing the fantastic or that fantasizes an honesty about its being fantasy.

Related Results

PHOTOGRAPHY AND IRONY: THE SAMUEL BUTLER PHOTOGRAPHY EXHIBITION AT THE TATE BRITAIN
PHOTOGRAPHY AND IRONY: THE SAMUEL BUTLER PHOTOGRAPHY EXHIBITION AT THE TATE BRITAIN
AN EXHIBITION of Samuel Butler's photography in Gallery Sixteen, an elegant rotunda room just off the entrance to the Tate Britain, offered a rare opportunity to see some of the ph...
Vulnerability, Ignorance, and Oppression
Vulnerability, Ignorance, and Oppression
This paper aims to understand the relationship between ignorance and vulnerability by drawing on recent work on the epistemology of ignorance. After elaborating how we might unders...
Tracing the Influence of Simone de Beauvoir in Judith Butler’s Work
Tracing the Influence of Simone de Beauvoir in Judith Butler’s Work
Beauvoir’s existentialist ethics relates to and informs eminently contemporary accounts of feminist ethics in the Western continental feminist canon. To date only a few scholars ha...
What’s the trouble with humanity? A feminist critique of Judith Butler’s ethics of vulnerability
What’s the trouble with humanity? A feminist critique of Judith Butler’s ethics of vulnerability
The article addresses Judith Butler’s thought on ethics of vulnerability. The main goal of the article is to approach the concepts of vulnerability, recognition and representation ...
Hobbes et Gassendi: la psychologie dans le projet mécaniste
Hobbes et Gassendi: la psychologie dans le projet mécaniste
L'amitié et l'affinité intellectuelle qui caractérisèrent les rapports de Hobbes avec Gassendi forment un tissu ténu dont il n'est point aisé de démêler la trame. Aux côtés de poin...
Global Counter-Enlightenment: Introductory remarks
Global Counter-Enlightenment: Introductory remarks
Although there is little historical evidence for a clear-cut dichotomy between Enlightenment and Counter-Enlightenment as two coherent and unchanging traditions, it still makes sen...
Judith Butler and Politics
Judith Butler and Politics
Judith Butler and Politics is the only monograph-length study of the work of Judith Butler to focus on the entire scope of their work, including the last decade of their writing. I...
Hobbes, the “Natural Seeds” of Religion and French Libertine Discourse
Hobbes, the “Natural Seeds” of Religion and French Libertine Discourse
Hobbes surely spent the ten years (1641–1651) of greatest significance for his philosophical career on the Continent, in France, above all, in Paris. It was during this period that...

Back to Top