Javascript must be enabled to continue!
COMPARISON OF FENTON 2013 AND INTERGROWTH-21ST GROWTH CHARTS IN ASSESSING NEONATAL GROWTH PATTERNS AND OUTCOMES IN A TERTIARY NICU IN INDIA
View through CrossRef
Background:Preterm and low-birth-weight infants are often assessed using standard growth charts. The Fenton 2013 chart, based on retrospective data from developed countries, and the INTERGROWTH-21st(IG-21st) chart, based on multiethnic prospective data, are commonly used standards. This study compares neonatal growth patterns using both charts and examines associated morbidities.Materials and Methods:We conducted a prospective observational study in the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) of Sri Guru Ram Das Institute of Medical Sciences (July 2024–Dec 2025). All inborn and outborn neonates (gestational age 24–40 weeks) admitted within 24 h of life were enrolled after informed parental consent. Exclusions: major congenital anomalies or lost to follow-up. Weight, length, and head circumference were recorded at birth and periodically until discharge, and plotted on Fenton 2013 and IG-21stcharts. Neonates were classified as small for gestational age (SGA; <10thcentile) or appropriate (10th–90th) and screened for extrauterine growth restriction (EUGR; <10thcentile at discharge). Common neonatal morbidities were recorded. Descriptive statistics (mean±SD, median[IQR], proportions) and inferential tests (t-test or Mann–Whitney U for continuous data; chi-square/Fisher’s exact for categorical data; Cohen’s kappa for chart agreement) were applied (SPSS v30.0). A p-value <0.05 was considered significant.Results:Of 600 NICU admissions, 358 neonates met inclusion criteria. Mean gestational age was 36.5±2.6 weeks and mean birth weight 2366±620 g. Males comprised 54% (n=194). Most were inborn (85%) and delivered by cesarean section (81.3%). Forty-seven percent were term (>37 week) and 46.9% had low birth weight (1.5–2.5 kg). By Fenton charts, 29.3% (n=105) were SGA at birth vs. 30.0% (n=110) by IG-21^st (p>0.05).By discharge, EUGR (weight <10thcentile) was 49.2% (n=176) by Fenton and 50.3% (n=180) by IG-21st(p>0.05). The proportion of SGA increased markedly from birth to discharge (Fig. 2). Agreement between charts was high for weight classification (Cohen’s κ≈0.90 at all timepoints, indicating almost-perfect concordance). Neonatal complications included sepsis (64/358, 17.9%), respiratory distress syndrome (RDS, 58/358, 16.2%), bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD, 23/358, 6.4%), necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC, 19/358, 5.3%), patent ductus arteriosus (PDA, 15/358, 4.2%), and retinopathy of prematurity (ROP, 6/358, 1.7%). Infants with EUGR had significantly higher rates of sepsis (29.5% vs 6.6%, p<0.001), RDS (22.7% vs 9.9%, p=0.0016), BPD (11.4% vs 1.6%, p<0.001), NEC (8.5% vs 2.2%, p=0.015), and PDA (6.8% vs 1.6%, p=0.029) compared to non-EUGR infants (Table 2); ROP was rare. Birth weight was significantly lower in the EUGR group (mean 2171±626 g vs 2554±646 g; p<0.00001). These findings indicate that systemic illnesses are associated with postnatal growth faltering.Conclusion:In this NICU cohort, IG-21stcharts identified a slightly higher proportion of SGA neonates than Fenton, but both showed excellent concordance for weight measurements. Nearly half of the infants experienced EUGR by discharge. Low birth weight and serious morbidities (sepsis, RDS, BPD,NEC, PDA) were significantly associated with EUGR. Early recognition of SGA and aggressive nutritional management may improve growth outcomes. Both chart types proved useful, and clinicians should be aware that a higher incidence of EUGR is detected in NICU populations regardless of chart chosen.
Medico Legal Publications
Title: COMPARISON OF FENTON 2013 AND INTERGROWTH-21ST GROWTH CHARTS IN ASSESSING NEONATAL GROWTH PATTERNS AND OUTCOMES IN A TERTIARY NICU IN INDIA
Description:
Background:Preterm and low-birth-weight infants are often assessed using standard growth charts.
The Fenton 2013 chart, based on retrospective data from developed countries, and the INTERGROWTH-21st(IG-21st) chart, based on multiethnic prospective data, are commonly used standards.
This study compares neonatal growth patterns using both charts and examines associated morbidities.
Materials and Methods:We conducted a prospective observational study in the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) of Sri Guru Ram Das Institute of Medical Sciences (July 2024–Dec 2025).
All inborn and outborn neonates (gestational age 24–40 weeks) admitted within 24 h of life were enrolled after informed parental consent.
Exclusions: major congenital anomalies or lost to follow-up.
Weight, length, and head circumference were recorded at birth and periodically until discharge, and plotted on Fenton 2013 and IG-21stcharts.
Neonates were classified as small for gestational age (SGA; <10thcentile) or appropriate (10th–90th) and screened for extrauterine growth restriction (EUGR; <10thcentile at discharge).
Common neonatal morbidities were recorded.
Descriptive statistics (mean±SD, median[IQR], proportions) and inferential tests (t-test or Mann–Whitney U for continuous data; chi-square/Fisher’s exact for categorical data; Cohen’s kappa for chart agreement) were applied (SPSS v30.
0).
A p-value <0.
05 was considered significant.
Results:Of 600 NICU admissions, 358 neonates met inclusion criteria.
Mean gestational age was 36.
5±2.
6 weeks and mean birth weight 2366±620 g.
Males comprised 54% (n=194).
Most were inborn (85%) and delivered by cesarean section (81.
3%).
Forty-seven percent were term (>37 week) and 46.
9% had low birth weight (1.
5–2.
5 kg).
By Fenton charts, 29.
3% (n=105) were SGA at birth vs.
30.
0% (n=110) by IG-21^st (p>0.
05).
By discharge, EUGR (weight <10thcentile) was 49.
2% (n=176) by Fenton and 50.
3% (n=180) by IG-21st(p>0.
05).
The proportion of SGA increased markedly from birth to discharge (Fig.
2).
Agreement between charts was high for weight classification (Cohen’s κ≈0.
90 at all timepoints, indicating almost-perfect concordance).
Neonatal complications included sepsis (64/358, 17.
9%), respiratory distress syndrome (RDS, 58/358, 16.
2%), bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD, 23/358, 6.
4%), necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC, 19/358, 5.
3%), patent ductus arteriosus (PDA, 15/358, 4.
2%), and retinopathy of prematurity (ROP, 6/358, 1.
7%).
Infants with EUGR had significantly higher rates of sepsis (29.
5% vs 6.
6%, p<0.
001), RDS (22.
7% vs 9.
9%, p=0.
0016), BPD (11.
4% vs 1.
6%, p<0.
001), NEC (8.
5% vs 2.
2%, p=0.
015), and PDA (6.
8% vs 1.
6%, p=0.
029) compared to non-EUGR infants (Table 2); ROP was rare.
Birth weight was significantly lower in the EUGR group (mean 2171±626 g vs 2554±646 g; p<0.
00001).
These findings indicate that systemic illnesses are associated with postnatal growth faltering.
Conclusion:In this NICU cohort, IG-21stcharts identified a slightly higher proportion of SGA neonates than Fenton, but both showed excellent concordance for weight measurements.
Nearly half of the infants experienced EUGR by discharge.
Low birth weight and serious morbidities (sepsis, RDS, BPD,NEC, PDA) were significantly associated with EUGR.
Early recognition of SGA and aggressive nutritional management may improve growth outcomes.
Both chart types proved useful, and clinicians should be aware that a higher incidence of EUGR is detected in NICU populations regardless of chart chosen.
Related Results
Extrauterine growth restriction in very low birth weight infants according to different growth charts: a retrospective 10 years observational study
Extrauterine growth restriction in very low birth weight infants according to different growth charts: a retrospective 10 years observational study
Abstract
Background
Extrauterine growth restriction (EUGR) is common among very low birth weight (VLBW) infants and associated with poor neurodevelopmental outcomes. Preva...
Specialized neonatal nursing skill development and nursing implementation initiatives in NICU
Specialized neonatal nursing skill development and nursing implementation initiatives in NICU
<p><strong>BACKGROUND</strong></p><p>Years of armed conflict, natural disasters, a pandemic, and restrictive social policies targeting women have made...
The clinical performance and population health impact of birth weight-for-gestational age indices with regard to adverse neonatal outcomes in term infants
The clinical performance and population health impact of birth weight-for-gestational age indices with regard to adverse neonatal outcomes in term infants
Abstract
Background
Despite the recent creation of several birth weight-for-gestational age references and...
“NICU Doesn’t Stop in the NICU”: Maternal Perspectives of the Impact of a NICU Experience over Time
“NICU Doesn’t Stop in the NICU”: Maternal Perspectives of the Impact of a NICU Experience over Time
Background: Despite the growing literature demonstrating the psychological impact of a NICU admission on parents, the longer-term adjustment to a NICU experience following an infan...
RELAÇÃO FAMILIAR NA UNIDADE DE TERAPIA INTENSIVA NEONATAL: REVISÃO INTEGRATIVA
RELAÇÃO FAMILIAR NA UNIDADE DE TERAPIA INTENSIVA NEONATAL: REVISÃO INTEGRATIVA
Objetivo: Identificar a produção do conhecimento, na literatura, acerca das relações familiares do neonato e os profissionais da Enfermagem atuantes na Unidade de Terapia Intensiva...
Atrazine Removal in Municipal Secondary Effluents by Fenton and Photo‐Fenton Treatments
Atrazine Removal in Municipal Secondary Effluents by Fenton and Photo‐Fenton Treatments
AbstractAlternative water sources, including effluents from municipal wastewater treatment plants (MWTP) are necessary to meet increasing water demand. Advanced oxidation processes...
Degradation of Phenol in Aqueous Solution by Fenton, Sono‐Fenton and Sono‐photo‐Fenton Methods
Degradation of Phenol in Aqueous Solution by Fenton, Sono‐Fenton and Sono‐photo‐Fenton Methods
AbstractThe present work focuses on the performance of Fenton, sono‐Fenton, and sono‐photo‐Fenton processes for the oxidation of phenol present in aqueous solution. The effects of ...
Performance of a local reference curve for predicting small for gestational age fetuses in pregnant women with HIV/AIDS
Performance of a local reference curve for predicting small for gestational age fetuses in pregnant women with HIV/AIDS
AbstractPurposeTo compare the performance of a local estimated fetal weight curve with curves established for other populations to predict small for gestational age (SGA) fetuses.M...

