Surgical Management of Painful Digital Neuroma: A Systematic Review

Abstract Background Neuromas of the digits can be a mentally and physically disabling condition for patients in this systematic review, the authors discuss a variety of surgical techniques for digital neuroma management. Aim of the Work This systematic review aims to analyze and combine the results of relevant studies on surgical treatment for digital neuroma. It aims to determine the overall success of the surgical procedure and identify which techniques are more effective. Patients and Methods Four databases, including Embase, Scopus, PubMed, and Google Scholar, were searched for relevant studies. The search spans the years 1990 to 2022. Out of 1490 initial studies, 672 remained after removing duplicates. After screening the Abstracts, 647 were excluded for various reasons, leaving 12 eligible studies for inclusion in the systematic review, which included a total of 309 patients. Outcomes reporting included the visual analogue scale (VAS) to report pain, patient satisfaction, the Semmes-Weinstein Monofilament Test, The two-point discrimination test, a non-standard ordinal scale and the mean follow-up duration. Results The studies included neuroma excision, neuroma excision (and implantation into adjacent tissues), centro-central union, proximal relocation, interdigital direct neurorrhaphy, nerve allograft reconstruction, regenerative peripheral interface, dorsal transposition and epineural coaptation, collagen conduits, and muscle-in-vein conduits (MVCs).The results show that a majority of patients achieved pain relief after surgery, with high levels of satisfaction reported in some studies. The most successful surgical approach was not determined since there were no statistically significant differences between the various surgical techniques. However, neuroma excision followed by nerve repair/reconstruction (centro-central union, proximal relocation, direct neurorrhaphy, nerve allograft, regenerative peripheral interface, dorsal transposition and nerve conduit )show magnificent results compared to neuroma excision alone with or without implantation. Factors such as old age, smoking, and high PROMIS Depression scores were found to be independently associated with higher levels of pain interference. Conclusion The results suggest that surgical treatment is effective in reducing pain levels, with most patients reporting complete pain relief or improvement. Neuroma excision followed by nerve repair/reconstruction was found to result in better outcomes compared to neuroma excision alone with or without implantation.