Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Algol anomaly or careful observations of its brightness? The values recorded for the magnitude of Algol in the medieval astronomical corpus

View through CrossRef
The historical evidence from the past two millennia show two problems concerning the star Algol (β Per): First, a critical variation in its brightness from a magnitude m ~ 2 in (1) Ptolemy’s Almagest (2nd century AD) and reported by (2) al-Ṣūfī (10th ct.) through its diminution to m = 4 in (3) the star catalog prepared by the Persian astronomers in service of the Yuan dynasty of China in the 13th ct. to becoming brighter, m = 3, as reported by (4) Ibn al-Shāṭir (14th ct.) and (5) Tycho Brahe (16th ct.). In the early modern period, it returned back to m ~ 2, as reported, for example, by Hevelius and Flamsteed (17th ct.), before the discovery of its periodic variability in 1783. Second, al-Ṣūfī reports it as a red star. We present detailed analyses of the sources (3) and (4) for the test of their accuracy and reliability. Our conservative hypothesis concerning the first problem is that the past astronomers observed the star at various phases of its 3-day period of variability. We reject the reddening to have arisen from the extinction due to either the Earth’s atmosphere or an interstellar medium. For resolving both problems, we instead speculate on astrophysical explanations for the observations. These are: copious dust produced as a result of arrested coronal mass ejections or pulverized planetary debris that resides close to the central binary before being dispersed; and a much-enhanced accretion rate that lead Algol into a W Ser-like state in which the primary was enveloped in an inflated accretion disk. We draw an analogy between the dimming of Algol and the recent dimming of Betelgeuse in order to highlight the value of historical observations for understanding astrophysical phenomena.
Title: Algol anomaly or careful observations of its brightness? The values recorded for the magnitude of Algol in the medieval astronomical corpus
Description:
The historical evidence from the past two millennia show two problems concerning the star Algol (β Per): First, a critical variation in its brightness from a magnitude m ~ 2 in (1) Ptolemy’s Almagest (2nd century AD) and reported by (2) al-Ṣūfī (10th ct.
) through its diminution to m = 4 in (3) the star catalog prepared by the Persian astronomers in service of the Yuan dynasty of China in the 13th ct.
to becoming brighter, m = 3, as reported by (4) Ibn al-Shāṭir (14th ct.
) and (5) Tycho Brahe (16th ct.
).
In the early modern period, it returned back to m ~ 2, as reported, for example, by Hevelius and Flamsteed (17th ct.
), before the discovery of its periodic variability in 1783.
Second, al-Ṣūfī reports it as a red star.
We present detailed analyses of the sources (3) and (4) for the test of their accuracy and reliability.
Our conservative hypothesis concerning the first problem is that the past astronomers observed the star at various phases of its 3-day period of variability.
We reject the reddening to have arisen from the extinction due to either the Earth’s atmosphere or an interstellar medium.
For resolving both problems, we instead speculate on astrophysical explanations for the observations.
These are: copious dust produced as a result of arrested coronal mass ejections or pulverized planetary debris that resides close to the central binary before being dispersed; and a much-enhanced accretion rate that lead Algol into a W Ser-like state in which the primary was enveloped in an inflated accretion disk.
We draw an analogy between the dimming of Algol and the recent dimming of Betelgeuse in order to highlight the value of historical observations for understanding astrophysical phenomena.

Related Results

Revamping the GFZ Energy Magnitude computation procedure to establish a new service
Revamping the GFZ Energy Magnitude computation procedure to establish a new service
<p>Location and magnitude are the primary information released by any seismological observatory to characterize an earthquake. Nowadays, the size of large enough eart...
A new MD-ML relationship for Mt. Etna earthquakes (Italy)
A new MD-ML relationship for Mt. Etna earthquakes (Italy)
<p class="Testoformula">A homogenous database of magnitude observations is a basic requirement for seismic hazard estimation and other seismic studies. Unfortunately, the mag...
PERBAIKAN KONTRAS CITRA MENGGUNAKAN TEKNIK BRIGHTNESS ADJUSTMENT UNTUK SISTEM EKSTRAKSI GARIS PANTAI
PERBAIKAN KONTRAS CITRA MENGGUNAKAN TEKNIK BRIGHTNESS ADJUSTMENT UNTUK SISTEM EKSTRAKSI GARIS PANTAI
This study has evaluated the application of brightness adjustment technique to improve image contrast in the framework of coastline extraction on video-based shoreline monitoring s...
Musical Scales and Brightness Evaluations: Effects of Pitch, Direction, and Scale Mode
Musical Scales and Brightness Evaluations: Effects of Pitch, Direction, and Scale Mode
A common form of synesthesia and nonsynesthetic cross-modal matching involves an association of visual brightness and auditory frequency, and the form of this association was studi...
Anomaly Detection Using Puzzle-Based Data Augmentation to Overcome Data Imbalances and Deficiencies
Anomaly Detection Using Puzzle-Based Data Augmentation to Overcome Data Imbalances and Deficiencies
Machine tools are used in a wide range of applications, and they can manufacture workpieces flexibly. Furthermore, they require maintenance; the overall costs include maintenance c...
Judging a book by its cover (and its background): effects of the metaphor intelligence is brightness on ratings of book images
Judging a book by its cover (and its background): effects of the metaphor intelligence is brightness on ratings of book images
Visual metaphors have been the focus of experimental and corpus studies aiming to determine whether metaphors are conceptual or purely linguistic. However, in visual metaphor resea...
Analysis of Light Pollution of the Night Sky in Toruń (Poland)
Analysis of Light Pollution of the Night Sky in Toruń (Poland)
Light pollution is one of the types of environmental pollution. The sky illuminated by the excessive light emission is an inherent element of the modern world. This phenomenon has ...
New Astronomy in Service of Old Astrology: Close Planetary Conjunctions in Pre-Modern China
New Astronomy in Service of Old Astrology: Close Planetary Conjunctions in Pre-Modern China
This article introduces various definitions and criteria for the astronomical phenomena of “encroachments” (close lunar and planetary conjunctions) in pre-modern China. With improv...

Recent Results

The mansio in Pisidia‘s Döşeme Boğazı: a unique building in Roman Asia Minor
The mansio in Pisidia‘s Döşeme Boğazı: a unique building in Roman Asia Minor
The Döşeme Boğazı (‘Pass with the Pavement’) is one of the ancient routes through the Taurus Mountains that connected the Anatolian interior with the southern coastal regions (fig....
Robert Smithson's Toxic Tour of Passaic, New Jersey
Robert Smithson's Toxic Tour of Passaic, New Jersey
No land artist of the 1960s was more influential at the time than Robert Smithson. If anything, earthworks such as theSpiral Jettyand essays such as “Frederick Law Olmsted and the ...
Vestibular, locomotor, and vestibulo-autonomic research: 50 years of collaboration with Bernard Cohen
Vestibular, locomotor, and vestibulo-autonomic research: 50 years of collaboration with Bernard Cohen
My collaboration on the vestibulo-ocular reflex with Bernard Cohen began in 1972. Until 2017, this collaboration included studies of saccades, quick phases of nystagmus, the introd...

Back to Top