Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Pulse Pressure versus Continuous Flow Monitoring for Fluid Responsiveness Prediction During Passive Leg Raising: A Prospective Diagnostic Accuracy Study
View through CrossRef
Abstract
Background
Accurate prediction of fluid responsiveness is essential in managing circulatory shock. While passive leg raising (PLR) is recommended in international guidelines, its diagnostic validity depends critically on the monitoring modality used to detect hemodynamic responses. In resource-limited settings, manual blood pressure measurement remains the predominant available technology, yet its adequacy for PLR interpretation has not been rigorously evaluated in an adequately powered study with an independent reference standard.
Objective
To compare the diagnostic accuracy of manual pulse pressure change (ΔPP%) versus continuous flow monitoring (USCOM-1A, ΔSV%) for predicting fluid responsiveness during PLR in ICU patients with undifferentiated shock, using echocardiographic cardiac output assessment as an independent reference standard.
Methods
Prospective single-center diagnostic accuracy study enrolling consecutive ICU patients with undifferentiated shock at Sina Educational and Medical Center, Tehran, Iran (2020–2021). A standardized PLR protocol was performed with simultaneous blinded measurements by three independent operators: manual blood pressure via calibrated sphygmomanometer, continuous flow monitoring via USCOM-1A, and echocardiographic velocity-time integral (VTI) measurement as the reference standard. Fluid responsiveness was defined as ≥ 15% cardiac output increase following 500 mL crystalloid challenge. Primary outcome was area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC). The study followed STARD 2015 guidelines (Ethics approval: IR.SBMU.PHARMACY.REC.1399.316).
Results
Of 124 patients analyzed (mean age 58.1 ± 19.8 years, 65.3% female), 58 (46.8%) were fluid responders. Continuous flow monitoring demonstrated acceptable diagnostic accuracy (AUC 0.712, 95%CI 0.622–0.802; sensitivity 81.0%; specificity 61.8%; NPV 79.2%). Manual pulse pressure demonstrated significantly inferior discrimination (AUC 0.601, 95%CI 0.502–0.700; DeLong test P = 0.029) with critically low sensitivity (32.8%) and clinically inadequate NPV (57.8%). Gray zone analysis (sensitivity and specificity both < 80%) identified that 41.9% of patients fell into an indeterminate range for manual pulse pressure versus only 22.6% for USCOM. Bootstrap-corrected performance estimates confirmed the robustness of findings (USCOM AUC 0.708; Manual PP AUC 0.596). Mean pulse pressure remained essentially unchanged during PLR (+ 0.4 ± 4.6 mmHg, P = 0.287) despite significant proportional increases in both systolic (+ 3.7%) and diastolic (+ 5.6%) pressures, and despite echocardiographically confirmed stroke volume augmentation (LVOT VTI + 15.9%). The correlation between ΔPP% and ΔSV% was weak (r = 0.39, R²=0.15). USCOM-derived and echocardiography-derived cardiac outputs showed good agreement at baseline (bias 0.08 L/min, limits of agreement − 1.12 to + 1.28 L/min).
Conclusions
Manual pulse pressure demonstrates insufficient sensitivity (32.8%) and inadequate NPV (57.8%) for reliable fluid responsiveness prediction during PLR in this single-center study, and our findings suggest it should be interpreted with considerable caution, particularly when the test result is negative. Continuous flow monitoring provides superior and clinically acceptable diagnostic accuracy and should be prioritized when available. The proportional pressure increase phenomenon provides a clear mechanistic explanation for this diagnostic failure. These findings require multicenter validation before definitive practice recommendations can be issued.
Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Title: Pulse Pressure versus Continuous Flow Monitoring for Fluid Responsiveness Prediction During Passive Leg Raising: A Prospective Diagnostic Accuracy Study
Description:
Abstract
Background
Accurate prediction of fluid responsiveness is essential in managing circulatory shock.
While passive leg raising (PLR) is recommended in international guidelines, its diagnostic validity depends critically on the monitoring modality used to detect hemodynamic responses.
In resource-limited settings, manual blood pressure measurement remains the predominant available technology, yet its adequacy for PLR interpretation has not been rigorously evaluated in an adequately powered study with an independent reference standard.
Objective
To compare the diagnostic accuracy of manual pulse pressure change (ΔPP%) versus continuous flow monitoring (USCOM-1A, ΔSV%) for predicting fluid responsiveness during PLR in ICU patients with undifferentiated shock, using echocardiographic cardiac output assessment as an independent reference standard.
Methods
Prospective single-center diagnostic accuracy study enrolling consecutive ICU patients with undifferentiated shock at Sina Educational and Medical Center, Tehran, Iran (2020–2021).
A standardized PLR protocol was performed with simultaneous blinded measurements by three independent operators: manual blood pressure via calibrated sphygmomanometer, continuous flow monitoring via USCOM-1A, and echocardiographic velocity-time integral (VTI) measurement as the reference standard.
Fluid responsiveness was defined as ≥ 15% cardiac output increase following 500 mL crystalloid challenge.
Primary outcome was area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC).
The study followed STARD 2015 guidelines (Ethics approval: IR.
SBMU.
PHARMACY.
REC.
1399.
316).
Results
Of 124 patients analyzed (mean age 58.
1 ± 19.
8 years, 65.
3% female), 58 (46.
8%) were fluid responders.
Continuous flow monitoring demonstrated acceptable diagnostic accuracy (AUC 0.
712, 95%CI 0.
622–0.
802; sensitivity 81.
0%; specificity 61.
8%; NPV 79.
2%).
Manual pulse pressure demonstrated significantly inferior discrimination (AUC 0.
601, 95%CI 0.
502–0.
700; DeLong test P = 0.
029) with critically low sensitivity (32.
8%) and clinically inadequate NPV (57.
8%).
Gray zone analysis (sensitivity and specificity both < 80%) identified that 41.
9% of patients fell into an indeterminate range for manual pulse pressure versus only 22.
6% for USCOM.
Bootstrap-corrected performance estimates confirmed the robustness of findings (USCOM AUC 0.
708; Manual PP AUC 0.
596).
Mean pulse pressure remained essentially unchanged during PLR (+ 0.
4 ± 4.
6 mmHg, P = 0.
287) despite significant proportional increases in both systolic (+ 3.
7%) and diastolic (+ 5.
6%) pressures, and despite echocardiographically confirmed stroke volume augmentation (LVOT VTI + 15.
9%).
The correlation between ΔPP% and ΔSV% was weak (r = 0.
39, R²=0.
15).
USCOM-derived and echocardiography-derived cardiac outputs showed good agreement at baseline (bias 0.
08 L/min, limits of agreement − 1.
12 to + 1.
28 L/min).
Conclusions
Manual pulse pressure demonstrates insufficient sensitivity (32.
8%) and inadequate NPV (57.
8%) for reliable fluid responsiveness prediction during PLR in this single-center study, and our findings suggest it should be interpreted with considerable caution, particularly when the test result is negative.
Continuous flow monitoring provides superior and clinically acceptable diagnostic accuracy and should be prioritized when available.
The proportional pressure increase phenomenon provides a clear mechanistic explanation for this diagnostic failure.
These findings require multicenter validation before definitive practice recommendations can be issued.
Related Results
Provocative Tests in Diagnosis of Thoracic Outlet Syndrome: A Narrative Review
Provocative Tests in Diagnosis of Thoracic Outlet Syndrome: A Narrative Review
Abstract
Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) is a group of conditions caused by the compression of the neurovascular bundle within the thoracic outlet. It is classified into three main ...
Muscle Metabolism during Exercise in Hemiparetic Patients
Muscle Metabolism during Exercise in Hemiparetic Patients
1. A group of eight male patients with moderate hemiparesis was studied at rest and during 40 min of exercise on four occasions. Both two-leg and one-leg exercise were performed an...
Analyzing Well Performance VII
Analyzing Well Performance VII
Introduction
Analyzing well performance is an important step toward increasing profits by improving production techniques. The analysis is made by field tests and...
Fine-Needle Aspiration Cytology and Salivary Gland Tumors: A Cross-Sectional Study
Fine-Needle Aspiration Cytology and Salivary Gland Tumors: A Cross-Sectional Study
Abstract
Introduction
Salivary gland neoplasms are relatively rare and diverse, requiring accurate preoperative diagnosis. Although the Milan System for Reporting Salivary Gland C...
Experimental Investigation of Permeability and Fluid Loss Properties of Water Based Mud Under High Pressure-High Temperature Conditions
Experimental Investigation of Permeability and Fluid Loss Properties of Water Based Mud Under High Pressure-High Temperature Conditions
Drilling in deeper formations and in high pressure and high temperature (HPHT) environments is a new frontier for the oil industry. Fifty years ago, no one would have imagined dril...
Suffering of Patients with Neurogenic Thoracic Outlet Syndrome (TOS); The First Qualitative study in TOS
Suffering of Patients with Neurogenic Thoracic Outlet Syndrome (TOS); The First Qualitative study in TOS
Abstract
Background
Diagnosis of neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome (nTOS) is hindered by symptom overlap with cervical radiculopathy, carpal tunnel syndrome, or psychosomatic dis...
Passive head-up tilt for predicting fluid responsiveness in critically ill patients
Passive head-up tilt for predicting fluid responsiveness in critically ill patients
Background: Assessment of fluid responsiveness is crucial for optimizing hemodynamic management in critically ill patients. Conventional tests such as the passive leg-raising (PLR)...
THE DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY OF MICROELECTRIC MECHANICAL SYSTEM-BASED CONTINUOUS PRESSURE MONITORING: RESULTS FROM TWO PROSPECTIVE CLINICAL TRIALS
THE DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY OF MICROELECTRIC MECHANICAL SYSTEM-BASED CONTINUOUS PRESSURE MONITORING: RESULTS FROM TWO PROSPECTIVE CLINICAL TRIALS
Acute Compartment Syndrome (ACS) is a painful condition caused by increased intracompartmental pressure (ICP) within a determined myofascial compartment [1]. ACS is a surgical emer...

