Javascript must be enabled to continue!
The Asymmetry Thesis and the Diversity of "Invalid" Argument-Forms
View through CrossRef
According to the Asymmetry Thesis, whereas there are many kinds of
argument-forms that make at least some of their instances valid, there is none that makes any of its instances invalid. To refute this thesis, a counterexample has been produced in the form of an argument-form whose premise-form's instances are all logically true and whose conclusion form's instances are all logically false. The purpose of this paper is to show that there are many more kinds of argument-forms that make some of their instances invalid and that, hence, are counterexamples refuting the Asymmetry Thesis.
Title: The Asymmetry Thesis and the Diversity of "Invalid" Argument-Forms
Description:
According to the Asymmetry Thesis, whereas there are many kinds of
argument-forms that make at least some of their instances valid, there is none that makes any of its instances invalid.
To refute this thesis, a counterexample has been produced in the form of an argument-form whose premise-form's instances are all logically true and whose conclusion form's instances are all logically false.
The purpose of this paper is to show that there are many more kinds of argument-forms that make some of their instances invalid and that, hence, are counterexamples refuting the Asymmetry Thesis.
Related Results
Is the leniency asymmetry really dead? Misinterpreting asymmetry effects in criminal jury deliberation
Is the leniency asymmetry really dead? Misinterpreting asymmetry effects in criminal jury deliberation
Early jury simulation research, reviewed and meta-anyalysed by MacCoun and Kerr (1988), suggested a leniency asymmetry in criminal jury deliberations such that a given faction favo...
Memory, the fork asymmetry, and the initial state
Memory, the fork asymmetry, and the initial state
AbstractWhy do we have records of the past and not the future? Entropic explanations for this ‘record asymmetry’ have been popular ever since Boltzmann. Foremost amongst these is A...
(Mis)managing diversity: exploring the dangers of diversity management orthodoxy
(Mis)managing diversity: exploring the dangers of diversity management orthodoxy
Purpose
– The purpose of this paper is to challenge the dominance of the mainstream discourse and practice of diversity management (DM) by identifying and problemat...
The Asymmetry of Counterfactual Dependence
The Asymmetry of Counterfactual Dependence
A certain type of counterfactual is thought to be intimately related to causation, control, and explanation. The time asymmetry of these phenomena therefore plausibly arises from a...
Back to the Present: How Not to Use Counterfactuals to Explain Causal Asymmetry
Back to the Present: How Not to Use Counterfactuals to Explain Causal Asymmetry
A plausible thought is that we should evaluate counterfactuals in the actual world by holding the present ‘fixed’; the state of the counterfactual world at the time of the antecede...
The colored-brain thesis
The colored-brain thesis
The “colored-brain thesis”, or strong qualitative physicalism, is discussed from historical and philosophical perspectives. This thesis was proposed by Thomas Case (1888), in a non...
Towards Language Sensitivity and Diversity in the Digital Humanities
Towards Language Sensitivity and Diversity in the Digital Humanities
English Recent years have seen a growing focus on diversity in the digital humanities, and yet there has been rather less work on geolinguistic diversity, and the research which ha...
A MINIMALIST EXPLANATION OF TRUTH’S ASYMMETRY
A MINIMALIST EXPLANATION OF TRUTH’S ASYMMETRY
Abstract
Suppose that Eleanor is drowsy. Truth’s asymmetry is illustrated by the following fact: while we accept that <Eleanor is drowsy> is true becau...