CONSTRAINTS ON CHONDRULE ORIGIN FROM PETROLOGY OF ISOTOPICALLY CHARACTERIZED CHONDRULES IN THE ALLENDE METEORITE

Petrographic and chemical features of Allende ferromagnesian chondrules previously analyzed for oxygen and silicon isotopes by Clayton et al. (1983a) provide additional information on chondrule origin. Allende, like other carbonaceous chondrites, contains two chondrule populations, but one of these is represented by only one chondrule in this isotopically characterized set. All Allende chondrules fall along an isotopic mixing line, probably defined by an 16O‐rich solid component and an isotopically heavier oxygen gaseous exchange component. Differences in the amounts of isotopic exchange for porphyritic and barred chondrules presumably resulted from varying degrees of melting. Those porphyritic chondrules containing abundant relict grains experienced the least isotopic exchange. Chondrules with high bulk FeO/(FeO + MgO) ratios apparently persisted longer as liquids and contain more of the exchange component. The distinct directions of oxygen isotopic exchange in chondrules from carbonaceous, ordinary, and enstatite chondrites indicate that each formed from different solid precursor materials. Silicon isotopic variations in Allende chondrules probably reflect evaporative loss of lighter isotopes; however, silicon loss is also controlled by chondrule sizes, which are unknown. Observed correlations point to the importance of kinetic factors in a gaseous nebula for chondrule genesis, and are not consistent with models that explain chondrules as mixtures of several solids with distinct oxygen and silicon isotopic compositions.