Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Ennius and the ‘Isiaci Coniectores’
View through CrossRef
At the end of the first book of Cicero's De diuinatione there occurs a tantalising passage containing a specific mention of the ‘Isiac diviners.’ It used to be attributed to Ennius by the earlier editors of that author, but since the time of Bothe this view has not been generally accepted. The passage runs ‘non habeo denique nauci Marsum augurem, non vicanos haruspices, non de circo astrologos, non Isiacos coniectores, non interpretes somniorum; non enim sunt ii aut scientia aut arte divini.’ The text is sound and there is no variant reading for the words ‘Isiaci coniectores’ which interest us most particularly in this study. The Italian colour of the passage (cf. ‘Marsus augur, de circo astrologi’) excludes the possibility of a Greek origin, and the question is merely to whom, Ennius or Cicero, the words ‘Isiaci coniectores’ should be assigned. It must be admitted that the words ‘non habeo … divini’ are not metrical and it would be hopeless to defend them in their present form as the ipsissima verba of Ennius. But the possibility that they contain a more or less close paraphrase of Ennius is suggested by the use of ‘non habeo … nauci,’ a phrase which Cicero never used. ‘Isiacus’ too is a rare word, which does not appear elsewhere in Republican Latin (v. infra pp. 58, 59, n. 21 and 22).
Title: Ennius and the ‘Isiaci Coniectores’
Description:
At the end of the first book of Cicero's De diuinatione there occurs a tantalising passage containing a specific mention of the ‘Isiac diviners.
’ It used to be attributed to Ennius by the earlier editors of that author, but since the time of Bothe this view has not been generally accepted.
The passage runs ‘non habeo denique nauci Marsum augurem, non vicanos haruspices, non de circo astrologos, non Isiacos coniectores, non interpretes somniorum; non enim sunt ii aut scientia aut arte divini.
’ The text is sound and there is no variant reading for the words ‘Isiaci coniectores’ which interest us most particularly in this study.
The Italian colour of the passage (cf.
‘Marsus augur, de circo astrologi’) excludes the possibility of a Greek origin, and the question is merely to whom, Ennius or Cicero, the words ‘Isiaci coniectores’ should be assigned.
It must be admitted that the words ‘non habeo … divini’ are not metrical and it would be hopeless to defend them in their present form as the ipsissima verba of Ennius.
But the possibility that they contain a more or less close paraphrase of Ennius is suggested by the use of ‘non habeo … nauci,’ a phrase which Cicero never used.
‘Isiacus’ too is a rare word, which does not appear elsewhere in Republican Latin (v.
infra pp.
58, 59, n.
21 and 22).
Related Results
Ennivs and the Punic Wars
Ennivs and the Punic Wars
Since the days of Merula it has been regularly assumed by editors and critics of Ennius that, despite the express statement of Cicero to the contrary, the Annales did contain some ...
Shored Against Our Ruins
Shored Against Our Ruins
These are exciting times for the study of Roman literature. New editions of the fragmentary poets and prose writers either have appeared or are in preparation, while renewed intere...
Recent Results
Los Diablos Rojos de Víctor Jara: un análisis coreográfico y musical
Los Diablos Rojos de Víctor Jara: un análisis coreográfico y musical
Este artículo es un estudio de la propuesta artística de Los Diablos Rojos de Víctor Jara, una comparsa de danza-música formada en el año 2009 para homenajear al cantautor en el dí...
Generics: some (non) specifics
Generics: some (non) specifics
AbstractThis paper is about an underappreciated aspect of generics: their non-specificity. Many uses of generics, utterances like ‘Seagulls swoop down to steal food’, express non-s...
In the mirror of AI: what is creativity?
In the mirror of AI: what is creativity?
AbstractMany discussions about AI seem to end up addessing the question of creativity. Can computers be considered creative? Or is it impossible for any entity to be considered cre...
Drawing learning: Letting art teach
Drawing learning: Letting art teach
Abstract Contextualized through the writing of Gert Biesta, this research proposes that as both artists and educators we should 'let art teach'. It proposes a position for student ...