Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Insights into the impact of base-excision–repair genes on immunotherapy response in solid tumors.
View through CrossRef
e14548
Background:
Base-excision repair (BER) is the primary pathway that removes ubiquitous single-base lesions from oxidative and alkylation stress, preserving genome integrity and preventing error-prone repair. When BER is disrupted, accumulation of DNA damage can heighten tumor immunogenicity—through increased mutational consequences and activation of cytosolic DNA–sensing pathways—creating a biologic context favorable to immune checkpoint blockade. We therefore asked whether BER gene alterations correlate with improved clinical outcomes to ICI across solid tumors.
Methods:
We pooled five published ICI cohorts with genomic/clinical annotation—DFCI Metastatic Melanoma (Science 2015); DFCI Clear-Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma (Science 2018/2019); MSK Melanoma (NEJM 2014); UCLA Metastatic Melanoma (Cell 2016); and MSK Immunotherapy/TMB (Nature Genetics 2019)—yielding 1,908 patients treated with anti-PD-1/PD-L1, anti-CTLA-4, or combination therapy across renal cell carcinoma, melanoma, non-small cell lung cancer, colorectal cancer, cancer of unknown primary, bladder cancer, breast cancer, glioma, esophagogastric cancer, non-melanoma skin cancer, and head & neck cancer. Data were retrieved via cBioPortal. Patients were classified as BER-altered if they harbored ≥1 qualifying event in MUTYH, PARP1, or NTHL1 (loss-of-function or pathogenic/likely-pathogenic missense; deep deletions; amplifications excluded); comparator: triple-wildtype. OS from ICI initiation was compared by Kaplan–Meier/log-rank; Cox models adjusted for age, tumor type, ICI class, and sex. Subg roup analyses focused on melanoma, NSCLC, and CRC.
Results:
78 patients were BER-altered, OF WHICH melanoma (53%), NSCLC (10%), and CRC (10%. Overall, BER-altered patients had longer OS than unaltered patients (mOS 32.4 vs 18.0 months; log-rank
p
= 0.0139). At the gene level, PARP1 alterations were associated with superior OS (median 32.4 vs 18.0 months; p = 0.0278). MUTYH alterations showed a favourable trend but did not reach statistical significance (mOS 49.3 vs 18.0 months;
p
= 0.299), and NTHL1 alterations were uncommon and showed similar survival to unaltered cases (mOS 20.1 vs 18.0 months;
p
= 0.870) By tumor type, NSCLC showed a favorable association (p = 0.0389), whereas melanoma was neutral (p = 0.561). Tumor mutational burden (exploratory): the BER-altered group had higher TMB than the unaltered group (median 21.7 vs 5.9 nonsynonymous mutations/Mb; p < 0.001). Co-mutations (BER-altered): the most common co-mutations were KMT2D, GRIN2A, PTPRT, BRAF, MUC16, and TERT.
Conclusions:
Alterations in MUTYH/PARP1/NTHL1—particularly PARP1—identify a subset of ICI-treated patients with improved OS, with the clearest effect in NSCLC and neutrality in melanoma.These findings support prospective validation and consideration of BER status, alongside genomic context such as TMB, in immunotherapy stratification.
Title: Insights into the impact of base-excision–repair genes on immunotherapy response in solid tumors.
Description:
e14548
Background:
Base-excision repair (BER) is the primary pathway that removes ubiquitous single-base lesions from oxidative and alkylation stress, preserving genome integrity and preventing error-prone repair.
When BER is disrupted, accumulation of DNA damage can heighten tumor immunogenicity—through increased mutational consequences and activation of cytosolic DNA–sensing pathways—creating a biologic context favorable to immune checkpoint blockade.
We therefore asked whether BER gene alterations correlate with improved clinical outcomes to ICI across solid tumors.
Methods:
We pooled five published ICI cohorts with genomic/clinical annotation—DFCI Metastatic Melanoma (Science 2015); DFCI Clear-Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma (Science 2018/2019); MSK Melanoma (NEJM 2014); UCLA Metastatic Melanoma (Cell 2016); and MSK Immunotherapy/TMB (Nature Genetics 2019)—yielding 1,908 patients treated with anti-PD-1/PD-L1, anti-CTLA-4, or combination therapy across renal cell carcinoma, melanoma, non-small cell lung cancer, colorectal cancer, cancer of unknown primary, bladder cancer, breast cancer, glioma, esophagogastric cancer, non-melanoma skin cancer, and head & neck cancer.
Data were retrieved via cBioPortal.
Patients were classified as BER-altered if they harbored ≥1 qualifying event in MUTYH, PARP1, or NTHL1 (loss-of-function or pathogenic/likely-pathogenic missense; deep deletions; amplifications excluded); comparator: triple-wildtype.
OS from ICI initiation was compared by Kaplan–Meier/log-rank; Cox models adjusted for age, tumor type, ICI class, and sex.
Subg roup analyses focused on melanoma, NSCLC, and CRC.
Results:
78 patients were BER-altered, OF WHICH melanoma (53%), NSCLC (10%), and CRC (10%.
Overall, BER-altered patients had longer OS than unaltered patients (mOS 32.
4 vs 18.
0 months; log-rank
p
= 0.
0139).
At the gene level, PARP1 alterations were associated with superior OS (median 32.
4 vs 18.
0 months; p = 0.
0278).
MUTYH alterations showed a favourable trend but did not reach statistical significance (mOS 49.
3 vs 18.
0 months;
p
= 0.
299), and NTHL1 alterations were uncommon and showed similar survival to unaltered cases (mOS 20.
1 vs 18.
0 months;
p
= 0.
870) By tumor type, NSCLC showed a favorable association (p = 0.
0389), whereas melanoma was neutral (p = 0.
561).
Tumor mutational burden (exploratory): the BER-altered group had higher TMB than the unaltered group (median 21.
7 vs 5.
9 nonsynonymous mutations/Mb; p < 0.
001).
Co-mutations (BER-altered): the most common co-mutations were KMT2D, GRIN2A, PTPRT, BRAF, MUC16, and TERT.
Conclusions:
Alterations in MUTYH/PARP1/NTHL1—particularly PARP1—identify a subset of ICI-treated patients with improved OS, with the clearest effect in NSCLC and neutrality in melanoma.
These findings support prospective validation and consideration of BER status, alongside genomic context such as TMB, in immunotherapy stratification.
Related Results
Complex Collision Tumors: A Systematic Review
Complex Collision Tumors: A Systematic Review
Abstract
Introduction: A collision tumor consists of two distinct neoplastic components located within the same organ, separated by stromal tissue, without histological intermixing...
Are Cervical Ribs Indicators of Childhood Cancer? A Narrative Review
Are Cervical Ribs Indicators of Childhood Cancer? A Narrative Review
Abstract
A cervical rib (CR), also known as a supernumerary or extra rib, is an additional rib that forms above the first rib, resulting from the overgrowth of the transverse proce...
Atypical Presentations of Pilonidal Sinus Disease: A Case Series with Literature Review
Atypical Presentations of Pilonidal Sinus Disease: A Case Series with Literature Review
Abstract
Introduction: Pilonidal sinus (PNS) typically arises in the sacrococcygeal region but can occasionally present in atypical locations, including the axilla, intermammary re...
Breast Carcinoma within Fibroadenoma: A Systematic Review
Breast Carcinoma within Fibroadenoma: A Systematic Review
Abstract
Introduction
Fibroadenoma is the most common benign breast lesion; however, it carries a potential risk of malignant transformation. This systematic review provides an ove...
Supplementary Data from Targeted BiTE Expression by an Oncolytic Vector Augments Therapeutic Efficacy Against Solid Tumors
Supplementary Data from Targeted BiTE Expression by an Oncolytic Vector Augments Therapeutic Efficacy Against Solid Tumors
<p>Supplementary Methods, Supplementary Figures S1-S15 Fig. S1. Purification and binding specificity of MV-encoded BiTEs. (A) Purification of MV-expressed BiTEs. Vero cells w...
Multiple Concurrent Pilonidal Sinuses: Case report and Literature review
Multiple Concurrent Pilonidal Sinuses: Case report and Literature review
Abstract
Introduction: Concurrent pilonidal sinuses (PNSs) at distinct locations are extremely rare. This report highlights an exceptional case of a young female presenting with th...
Abstract A21: Enhancing chemotherapeutic responses in CNS malignancy through suppression of hyperactive DNA damage repair pathways
Abstract A21: Enhancing chemotherapeutic responses in CNS malignancy through suppression of hyperactive DNA damage repair pathways
Abstract
Introduction: We are targeting DNA repair pathways to enhance existing chemoradiotherapeutic strategies against medulloblastoma (MB) and malignant glioma (M...
Systems-level immune profiling in children with solid tumors
Systems-level immune profiling in children with solid tumors
<p dir="ltr">Childhood cancer is a leading cause of disease-related death in children, and despite major improvements in survival over the past decades, around 15% of affecte...

