Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Civil Disobedience, Epistocracy, and the Question of whether Superior Political Judgment Defeats Majority Authority
View through CrossRef
Abstract
I outline a new approach to the question of when civil disobedience is legitimate by drawing on insights from the epistocracy literature. I argue that civil disobedience and epistocracy are similar in the sense that they both involve the idea that superior political judgment defeats majority authority, because this can lead to correct, i.e. just, prudent or morally right, political decisions. By reflecting on the question of when superior political judgment defeats majority authority in the epistocracy case, I identify considerations that also apply to the disobedience context. I conclude that disobedience in protest of law X performed by agents who know that X is wrong is legitimate when: 1) it is not reasonably disputable that the civil dissenter knows that X is wrong 2) the adoption of X is a high-stakes political decision and 3) no destabilizing effects ensue.
Title: Civil Disobedience, Epistocracy, and the Question of whether Superior Political Judgment Defeats Majority Authority
Description:
Abstract
I outline a new approach to the question of when civil disobedience is legitimate by drawing on insights from the epistocracy literature.
I argue that civil disobedience and epistocracy are similar in the sense that they both involve the idea that superior political judgment defeats majority authority, because this can lead to correct, i.
e.
just, prudent or morally right, political decisions.
By reflecting on the question of when superior political judgment defeats majority authority in the epistocracy case, I identify considerations that also apply to the disobedience context.
I conclude that disobedience in protest of law X performed by agents who know that X is wrong is legitimate when: 1) it is not reasonably disputable that the civil dissenter knows that X is wrong 2) the adoption of X is a high-stakes political decision and 3) no destabilizing effects ensue.
Related Results
The Analysis of the Relationship between God, Religion and Politics in Thomas Hobbes’s Leviathan and De Cive
The Analysis of the Relationship between God, Religion and Politics in Thomas Hobbes’s Leviathan and De Cive
Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679) was a
significant political theorist who could be regarded as the founder of social
contract theories. Hobbes’s philosophy is worthy of attention in the h...
Authority Through Freedom. On Freire’s Radicalisation of the Authority-Freedom Problem in Education
Authority Through Freedom. On Freire’s Radicalisation of the Authority-Freedom Problem in Education
Paulo Freire’s approach to the question of ‘authority and freedom’ in education and teaching (as well as in the political sphere), takes its cue from his early and radical approach...
Comic Authority in Aristophanes’ Knights
Comic Authority in Aristophanes’ Knights
This article investigates the relationship between comic speech and political authority in democratic Athens through a reading of Aristophanes’ Knights. The article surveys three d...
William Morris and the Judgment of God
William Morris and the Judgment of God
William Morris once said to a friend, “if there is a God, He never meant us to know much about Himself, or indeed to concern ourselves about Him at all.” The remark indicates a rel...
Civil Litigation 2020-2021
Civil Litigation 2020-2021
Civil Litigation introduces the processes and procedures involved in making and defending civil litigation claims. Following the chronological progression of a civil litigation cla...
“By Instruments her Powers Appeare”: Music and Authority in the Reign of Queen Elizabeth I
“By Instruments her Powers Appeare”: Music and Authority in the Reign of Queen Elizabeth I
Queen Elizabeth I’s musical talents and the elaborate music of her courtly entertainments are widely acknowledged. However, while the effect of Elizabeth’s gender on her authority ...
Ernest Barker and Greek Political Thought: Plato
Ernest Barker and Greek Political Thought: Plato
For much of the twentieth century Ernest Barker was the most frequently cited authority on Greek political thought in the English-speaking world. The centenary of his first publica...
Post-Political Theatre versus the Theatre of Political Struggle
Post-Political Theatre versus the Theatre of Political Struggle
In this article Bérénice Hamidi-Kim tests the hypothesis that two conflicting interpretations of the notion of ‘political theatre’ exist on the French stage today. She suggests tha...