Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Utilitarianism for a Broken World
View through CrossRef
Drawing on the author's recent bookEthics for a Broken World, this article explores the philosophical implications of the fact that climate change – or something like it – might lead to abroken worldwhere resources are insufficient to meet everyone's basic needs, and where our affluent way of life is no longer an option. It argues that the broken world has an impact, not only on applied ethics, but also on moral theory. It then explores that impact. The article first argues that the broken world creates severe difficulties for both libertarians and contractualists. It then explores the impact of the broken world on utilitarianism – and especially on reflective equilibrium arguments for rule-utilitarianism. The article concludes that, while such arguments may still be viable, the form of rule-utilitarianism that results will be less moderate and less liberal than contemporary rule-utilitarians might hope.
Title: Utilitarianism for a Broken World
Description:
Drawing on the author's recent bookEthics for a Broken World, this article explores the philosophical implications of the fact that climate change – or something like it – might lead to abroken worldwhere resources are insufficient to meet everyone's basic needs, and where our affluent way of life is no longer an option.
It argues that the broken world has an impact, not only on applied ethics, but also on moral theory.
It then explores that impact.
The article first argues that the broken world creates severe difficulties for both libertarians and contractualists.
It then explores the impact of the broken world on utilitarianism – and especially on reflective equilibrium arguments for rule-utilitarianism.
The article concludes that, while such arguments may still be viable, the form of rule-utilitarianism that results will be less moderate and less liberal than contemporary rule-utilitarians might hope.
Related Results
The Self-other Asymmetry and Act-utilitarianism
The Self-other Asymmetry and Act-utilitarianism
The self-other asymmetry is a prominent and important feature of common-sense morality. It is also a feature that does not find a home in standard versions of act-utilitarianism. T...
Of Broken Seals and Broken Promises: Attributing Intention at the IAEA
Of Broken Seals and Broken Promises: Attributing Intention at the IAEA
In the world of global politics, talk is cheap. States sign negotiated agreements, but a treaty without an enforcement mechanism is considered weak, because states are not expected...
Disorderly community partners and broken windows policing
Disorderly community partners and broken windows policing
How do residents in community groups define deviance, community, and their relationship to local government? Relying upon approximately two years of multi-method ethnography, I arg...
Broken Home as Inspiration in the Creative Process of Painting Art
Broken Home as Inspiration in the Creative Process of Painting Art
A broken home is defined as a family condition that is not harmonious and does not function like a peaceful and prosperous family, due to frequent disturbances and conflicts that l...
The New Aesthetic of the Late Nineteen Twenties Reconsidering the Periodization of the Interwar Avant-Gardes
The New Aesthetic of the Late Nineteen Twenties Reconsidering the Periodization of the Interwar Avant-Gardes
AbstractThe avant-gardes of the nineteen twenties are discussed in the art historical literature as the art products of a rarely upbeat decade, which featured great utopian aspirat...
Mill and Sidgwick, Imperialism and Racism
Mill and Sidgwick, Imperialism and Racism
This essay is in effect something of a self-review of my bookHenry Sidgwick: Eye of the Universe(2004) and of the volume, co-edited with Georgios Varouxakis,Utilitarianism and Empi...
Books before Chocolate? The Insufficiency of Mill's Evidence for Higher Pleasures
Books before Chocolate? The Insufficiency of Mill's Evidence for Higher Pleasures
Recent attempts to defend Mill's account of higher and lower pleasures have overlooked a critical flaw in Mill's argument. Mill considers the question of pleasure and preference as...
Peter Singer: Η ηθική σήμερα
Peter Singer: Η ηθική σήμερα
On May 2015 the influential moral philosopher Peter Singer, professor of Applied Ethics at Princeton University, was honored by the National and Kapodistrian University of Athens w...
Recent Results
Race and the Senses: Toward Articulating the Sensory Apparatus of Race
Race and the Senses: Toward Articulating the Sensory Apparatus of Race
Abstract
This article provides a preliminary exploration into the relationship between the bodily senses and race. Seeking insight into what Merleau-Ponty called a b...
Of Broken Seals and Broken Promises: Attributing Intention at the IAEA
Of Broken Seals and Broken Promises: Attributing Intention at the IAEA
In the world of global politics, talk is cheap. States sign negotiated agreements, but a treaty without an enforcement mechanism is considered weak, because states are not expected...
The Colour of Film-Philosophy
The Colour of Film-Philosophy
This article draws upon the work of Sylvia Wynter and W.E.B. Du Bois in order to propose that film-philosophy has historically not paid due attention to race. Drawing upon the form...
Symmetry as an Inter-Cultural Feature Constituting Beauty: Implicit and Explicit Beauty Evaluation of Visual Symmetry in Japan
Symmetry as an Inter-Cultural Feature Constituting Beauty: Implicit and Explicit Beauty Evaluation of Visual Symmetry in Japan
Symmetry has been recognized as one of the most important visual features to predict aesthetic preferences and was discussed as a potentially universal feature of beauty judgments....