Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Truthmaking
View through CrossRef
Truthmaking is the metaphysical exploration of the idea that what is true depends upon what exists. Truthmaker theorists argue about what the truthmaking relation involves, which truths require truthmakers, and what those truthmakers are. This Element covers the dominant views on these core issues in truthmaking. It also explores some key metaphysical topics and debates that are usefully approached by employing the tools of truthmaker theory: the debate between presentists and eternalists over the existence of entities from the past, and the debate between actualists and possibilists over merely possible states of affairs. In the final section, the Element explores how to think about truthmakers for truths involving social constructions.
Title: Truthmaking
Description:
Truthmaking is the metaphysical exploration of the idea that what is true depends upon what exists.
Truthmaker theorists argue about what the truthmaking relation involves, which truths require truthmakers, and what those truthmakers are.
This Element covers the dominant views on these core issues in truthmaking.
It also explores some key metaphysical topics and debates that are usefully approached by employing the tools of truthmaker theory: the debate between presentists and eternalists over the existence of entities from the past, and the debate between actualists and possibilists over merely possible states of affairs.
In the final section, the Element explores how to think about truthmakers for truths involving social constructions.
Related Results
Deflating Deflationary Truthmaking
Deflating Deflationary Truthmaking
AbstractIn this paper we confront a challenge to truthmaker theory that is analogous to the objections raised by deflationists against substantive theories of truth. Several critic...
Truthmaking
Truthmaking
Truthmaking is the relationship that holds between truths and the objects in the world in virtue of which those truths are true. Truthmaker theorists deploy the idea of truthmaking...
Variable Objects and Truthmaking
Variable Objects and Truthmaking
Noun phrases like the number of people that can fit into the bus or the book John needs to write are an extremely puzzling linguistic phenomenon. This chapter argues that such noun...
A Sketch of (an Actually Serious) Meinongian Presentism
A Sketch of (an Actually Serious) Meinongian Presentism
AbstractIn this paper I shall “draw” a sketch of a version of Meinongian Presentism. After having briefly presented some data that presentists need to explain and three problems th...
Truthmaking, Supervenience, and Reduction
Truthmaking, Supervenience, and Reduction
There are two main theories of ontological commitment: the quantifier view, and the truthmaker view. Since there are some truths that apparently commit us to certain entities, but ...
Essence and Existence
Essence and Existence
This book is a collection of essays written by Bob Hale (three co-authored), with a critical introduction from Kit Fine. They comprise Hale’s final years of work, adding to and ext...
Introduction
Introduction
Kit Fine offers a critical introduction to the book, discussing in detail the two chapters in the volume that are on truthmaking—Chapter 6 on truthmakers for universal statements a...
Which Fitch?
Which Fitch?
Abstract
Jago (2019) uses a Fitch-style argument in an attempt to demonstrate that every truth has a truthmaker (maximalism). But Trueman (forthcoming) shows that th...

