Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Evaluating Microphysics, Cumulus, and Lightning Parameterization Schemes in WRF Model for Thunderstorm Simulation Over East India
View through CrossRef
   Lightning originates from electrical discharges driven by the non-inductive charging mechanism within thunderstorms. The charge separation in these regions is governed by the surrounding convective environment, storm dynamics, and microphysical processes, including updraft velocity and ice content, which intensify the storm's electric field. In recent decades, advances in understanding cloud microphysics, charge separation mechanisms, and thundercloud electrical structure have significantly improved lightning forecasting. The selection and tuning of parameterization schemes, particularly for microphysics (MP), cumulus (Cu), and lightning (LP) processes, play a critical role in enhancing model performance and accuracy.   This study uses various parameterization schemes to evaluate the performance of the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model in simulating lightning and thunderstorm events. A severe thunderstorm event on May 14, 2022, over eastern India (West Bengal and Jharkhand), which recorded a peak 30-minute flash count of ~8000 flashes observed by the Indian Lightning Location Network (ILLN) was simulated in the WRF model. A total of 57 combinations of MP, Cu, and LP schemes were tested, using three nested domains (27 km, 9 km, 3 km) and analyzed the output of the inner domain (3 km). Seven MP schemes (WSM-6, Goddard, Thompson, Milbrandt, Morrison, WDM-5, WDM-6), two Cu schemes (Kain-Fritsch, Multi Kain-Fritsch), and two LP schemes (LP1: vertical velocity-based; LP2: 20 dBZ reflectivity-based) were assessed.    Results show better performance of LP2 over LP1 with higher correlation and lower standard deviation with the observed flash counts. For cumulus parameterization, Kain-Fritsch (KF) turned off for the inner domain, and achieved strong performance (correlation: 0.75–0.95) with lower RMSE and standard deviation. Among MP schemes, Morrison, Goddard, and WDM-6 consistently performed well across different combinations. The best-performing simulations included Goddard (LP2, KF on), Morrison (LP2, KF on), WDM-6 (LP2, KF off), and WDM-5 (LP2, KF on), achieving correlations of 0.94, 0.93, 0.91, and 0.91 with observed flash counts, respectively. This study underscores the WRF model's capability in simulating lightning activity with optimal parameterization combinations, particularly LP2 and KF schemes. These findings provide promising results for real-time lightning forecasting, aiding in mitigating lightning-related hazards.
Title: Evaluating Microphysics, Cumulus, and Lightning Parameterization Schemes in WRF Model for Thunderstorm Simulation Over East India
Description:
   Lightning originates from electrical discharges driven by the non-inductive charging mechanism within thunderstorms.
The charge separation in these regions is governed by the surrounding convective environment, storm dynamics, and microphysical processes, including updraft velocity and ice content, which intensify the storm's electric field.
In recent decades, advances in understanding cloud microphysics, charge separation mechanisms, and thundercloud electrical structure have significantly improved lightning forecasting.
The selection and tuning of parameterization schemes, particularly for microphysics (MP), cumulus (Cu), and lightning (LP) processes, play a critical role in enhancing model performance and accuracy.
   This study uses various parameterization schemes to evaluate the performance of the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model in simulating lightning and thunderstorm events.
A severe thunderstorm event on May 14, 2022, over eastern India (West Bengal and Jharkhand), which recorded a peak 30-minute flash count of ~8000 flashes observed by the Indian Lightning Location Network (ILLN) was simulated in the WRF model.
A total of 57 combinations of MP, Cu, and LP schemes were tested, using three nested domains (27 km, 9 km, 3 km) and analyzed the output of the inner domain (3 km).
Seven MP schemes (WSM-6, Goddard, Thompson, Milbrandt, Morrison, WDM-5, WDM-6), two Cu schemes (Kain-Fritsch, Multi Kain-Fritsch), and two LP schemes (LP1: vertical velocity-based; LP2: 20 dBZ reflectivity-based) were assessed.
    Results show better performance of LP2 over LP1 with higher correlation and lower standard deviation with the observed flash counts.
For cumulus parameterization, Kain-Fritsch (KF) turned off for the inner domain, and achieved strong performance (correlation: 0.
75–0.
95) with lower RMSE and standard deviation.
Among MP schemes, Morrison, Goddard, and WDM-6 consistently performed well across different combinations.
The best-performing simulations included Goddard (LP2, KF on), Morrison (LP2, KF on), WDM-6 (LP2, KF off), and WDM-5 (LP2, KF on), achieving correlations of 0.
94, 0.
93, 0.
91, and 0.
91 with observed flash counts, respectively.
This study underscores the WRF model's capability in simulating lightning activity with optimal parameterization combinations, particularly LP2 and KF schemes.
These findings provide promising results for real-time lightning forecasting, aiding in mitigating lightning-related hazards.
Related Results
Localizaciones con impactos de rayos recurrentes : aportación a la distribución geográfica de rayos con corrientes extremas y a la caracterización de rayos que afectan aerogeneradores
Localizaciones con impactos de rayos recurrentes : aportación a la distribución geográfica de rayos con corrientes extremas y a la caracterización de rayos que afectan aerogeneradores
(English) Nowadays, lightning presents a challenge to the proper functioning of an increasingly complex electrical system. One of the most sensitive and exposed to lightning elemen...
Radio pulse power distribution of lightning in Jupiter's 2021-2022 stealth superstorms
Radio pulse power distribution of lightning in Jupiter's 2021-2022 stealth superstorms
OverviewJovian lightning has been investigated by every spacecraft mission that visited Jupiter prior to Juno. Lightning is valued because it traces locations with active moist con...
Integrated Thermodynamic and Microphysical Framework for Thunderstorm and Lightning Prediction over Bangladesh
Integrated Thermodynamic and Microphysical Framework for Thunderstorm and Lightning Prediction over Bangladesh
Abstract
Bangladesh is located within the highly lightning-prone region (30N-30S belt) and experiences significant casualties and property loss, particularly during...
Long-range Lightning Interferometry (A Simulation Study)
Long-range Lightning Interferometry (A Simulation Study)
Traditional long-range lightning detection and location networks use Time-of-Arrival (TOA) differences, and a single timestamp to locate lightning events. For long propagation dist...
Development of a data-driven lightning model for implementation in Global Climate Models
Development of a data-driven lightning model for implementation in Global Climate Models
This study proposes a new global-scale lightning model, predicting
lightning rates from large-scale climatic variables. Using satellite
lightning records spanning a period of 29 ye...
Seasonal prediction of Indian summer monsoon using WRF: A dynamical downscaling perspective
Seasonal prediction of Indian summer monsoon using WRF: A dynamical downscaling perspective
Abstract
Seasonal forecasting of the Indian summer monsoon by dynamically downscaling the CFSv2 output using a high resolution WRF model over the hindcast period of 1982–20...
Lightning Activity in China and Its Optical Characteristics Observed by Geostationary Satellite
Lightning Activity in China and Its Optical Characteristics Observed by Geostationary Satellite
Lightning now has designated as an Essential Climate Variable in the Global Climate Observing System to understand the climate change. Lightning detection from geostationary satell...
Análisis de la actividad de rayos y de tormentas relacionadas con la producción de rayos gamma terrestres
Análisis de la actividad de rayos y de tormentas relacionadas con la producción de rayos gamma terrestres
Terrestrial Gamma ray Flashes (TGFs) have been known since 20 years ago, but since the first moment of the discovery it was clear that they were related to lightning and thundersto...

