Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Did Hans Memling Employ Optical Projections When Painting Flower Still-Life?
View through CrossRef
David Hockney has recently hypothesized that some early Renaissance painters employed optical devices such as concave mirrors to project images of a scene or part of a scene onto their supports, which they then traced or painted over. As one of many examples, he has claimed that Hans Memling (ca. 1440–1494) built an optical projector to create his Flower Still Life, specifically when rendering its carpet. The author's perspective analysis on the image of this carpet shows that, while there is a “break” in perspective consistent with refocusing or tipping of an optical projector, there are also other larger, more significant perspective deviations that are inconsistent with the use of a projector. After presenting a simple sensitivity analysis of these results and rebutting anticipated objections, the author concludes by rejecting the claim that optical projections were used in the creation of this still life.
Title: Did Hans Memling Employ Optical Projections When Painting Flower Still-Life?
Description:
David Hockney has recently hypothesized that some early Renaissance painters employed optical devices such as concave mirrors to project images of a scene or part of a scene onto their supports, which they then traced or painted over.
As one of many examples, he has claimed that Hans Memling (ca.
1440–1494) built an optical projector to create his Flower Still Life, specifically when rendering its carpet.
The author's perspective analysis on the image of this carpet shows that, while there is a “break” in perspective consistent with refocusing or tipping of an optical projector, there are also other larger, more significant perspective deviations that are inconsistent with the use of a projector.
After presenting a simple sensitivity analysis of these results and rebutting anticipated objections, the author concludes by rejecting the claim that optical projections were used in the creation of this still life.
Related Results
De constructie van Memlings Van Nieuwenhoveportret: een probleem van interpretatie van de voorbereidende tekening
De constructie van Memlings Van Nieuwenhoveportret: een probleem van interpretatie van de voorbereidende tekening
AbstractSince the advent of infrared photography and in particular infrared reflectography (Note I), study of the underdrawing has increasingly become a fundamental part of art his...
Organ and Machinery Projections in Florensky’s Philosophy and Vertov’s Cinematography
Organ and Machinery Projections in Florensky’s Philosophy and Vertov’s Cinematography
My article is dedicated to the Kapp’s theory of organ projections in the first half of the XX century in Russia. I research that the philosopher P. Florensky and the filmmaker Dzig...
Optical properties of non-dilute metal-insulator composites
Optical properties of non-dilute metal-insulator composites
The description of the optical properties of metal-insulator composites in the non-dilute region is a long standing problem. In this letter we extract the spectral density function...
Chinese Flower and Bird Painting: A New Form of Art Therapy for Depression
Chinese Flower and Bird Painting: A New Form of Art Therapy for Depression
Depression is a complex psychological disorder. Although psychological counseling and traditional Western art therapy have obtained robust results in the diagnosis and treatment of...
imitateur moderne des Primitifs flamands établi en Espagne: le Faussaire de Valls Marín
imitateur moderne des Primitifs flamands établi en Espagne: le Faussaire de Valls Marín
Le Faussaire de Valls Marín peut être considéré comme l’un des imitateurs de la peinture des anciens Pays-Bas ayant connu le plus grand succès, une sorte de Joseph Van der Veken ib...
From the Editor
From the Editor
This issue of Projections features an impressive diversity of research questions and research methods. In our first article, Timothy Justus investigates the question of how film mu...
Future scenarios of global plastic waste generation and disposal
Future scenarios of global plastic waste generation and disposal
AbstractThe accumulation of mismanaged plastic waste (MPW) in the environment is a global growing concern. Knowing with precision where litter is generated is important to target p...