Outcome of wheeze in childhood: the influence of atopy

We have previously demonstrated that the adult outcome of childhood asthma differs from that of wheeze occurring only in the presence of infection. This paper examines the role of atopy in relation to outcome. We investigated the atopic status, current symptoms and bronchial reactivity to methacholine of 235 subjects aged 34-40 yrs, originally classified at age 10-15 yrs as having asthma (asthma group), wheeze only in the presence of infection (wheezy group), or no respiratory symptoms (comparison group). Subjects from the original asthma group were more likely to be atopic as defined by skin test reactivity, total serum immunoglobulin E (IgE) measurement or specific IgE radio allergosorbent test (RAST) measurement than those from the wheezy group. The wheezy group differed significantly from the reference group only in RAST results, when other variables were taken into account. In a logistic regression model, the important independent predictors for adult wheezing symptoms were original group, atopy and current smoking. Methacholine responsiveness was independently associated with original group (the asthma group were more likely to respond positively), atopy and female gender. The results suggest that atopy is an important predictor for wheeze and bronchial hyperreactivity in middle age. However, the difference in outcome for children who had asthma compared to those who had wheeze only in the presence of infection cannot be explained by atopy alone.