Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Sitting Forward or Sitting Back: Highbrow v. Middlebrow Reading

View through CrossRef
This article begins by asserting that the distinction between high and middlebrow literary texts rests fundamentally not on literary merit or cultural hierarchies but on the culture and practices of reading as they changed and developed in the first half of the twentieth century. It explores the difficulties of drawing a firm dividing line between high and middlebrow experienced by contemporary critical and cultural commentators such as Cyril Connolly, Q. D. Leavis and George Orwell, and argues that what was crucial for these commentators was not so much the precise boundaries they drew as the fact of drawing them. It suggests that we need to find new ways of thinking about the literature of the first half of the twentieth century that avoid simply replicating the snobberies and anxieties of that period. Following a suggestion in Michel de Certeau's The Practice of Everyday Life, it examines the reading bodies implied by the highbrow and the middlebrow in order to tease out some of the wider cultural implications of the battle of the brows. Firstly, it suggests that the difference between high and middlebrow texts, at its most basic, might simply be simply a matter of sitting forward or sitting back: of those texts that are read at a desk and those read while relaxing. It proposes an ethnography of the two groups of readers, and considers the culture of leisure that shapes middlebrow reading practices, and the institution of university English Literature that shapes those of the highbrow. Finally, it looks at the places and times where these distinctions start to break down, examining the reading surveys conducted by Mass Observation, and considering the phenomenon of Penguin Books and suggesting that an examination of the lived experience of readers presents a picture that is more various, complicated and resistant than neat theorising would allow.
Edinburgh University Press
Title: Sitting Forward or Sitting Back: Highbrow v. Middlebrow Reading
Description:
This article begins by asserting that the distinction between high and middlebrow literary texts rests fundamentally not on literary merit or cultural hierarchies but on the culture and practices of reading as they changed and developed in the first half of the twentieth century.
It explores the difficulties of drawing a firm dividing line between high and middlebrow experienced by contemporary critical and cultural commentators such as Cyril Connolly, Q.
D.
Leavis and George Orwell, and argues that what was crucial for these commentators was not so much the precise boundaries they drew as the fact of drawing them.
It suggests that we need to find new ways of thinking about the literature of the first half of the twentieth century that avoid simply replicating the snobberies and anxieties of that period.
Following a suggestion in Michel de Certeau's The Practice of Everyday Life, it examines the reading bodies implied by the highbrow and the middlebrow in order to tease out some of the wider cultural implications of the battle of the brows.
Firstly, it suggests that the difference between high and middlebrow texts, at its most basic, might simply be simply a matter of sitting forward or sitting back: of those texts that are read at a desk and those read while relaxing.
It proposes an ethnography of the two groups of readers, and considers the culture of leisure that shapes middlebrow reading practices, and the institution of university English Literature that shapes those of the highbrow.
Finally, it looks at the places and times where these distinctions start to break down, examining the reading surveys conducted by Mass Observation, and considering the phenomenon of Penguin Books and suggesting that an examination of the lived experience of readers presents a picture that is more various, complicated and resistant than neat theorising would allow.

Related Results

Genre and Stylistic Features of the Modern Audiobook
Genre and Stylistic Features of the Modern Audiobook
Modern technological conditions make it possible to create, quickly replicate and use audio books conveniently. Audio books are one of the fastest growing segments of the global pu...
Sitting Bull And Geronimo: A Comparison Of Their Military And Religious Leadership
Sitting Bull And Geronimo: A Comparison Of Their Military And Religious Leadership
In the history of the American West, hundreds of books have been written about Indian Leaders. Two of the most famous leaders are Sitting Bull and Geronimo. However, every history ...
Musicological Omnivory in the Neoliberal University
Musicological Omnivory in the Neoliberal University
This essay attributes the rise of inclusive values in recent musicological work to multicultural and neoliberal reforms in American universities. Musicological inclusivity is chara...
A Study on the Using Paratexts for Reading of Children: Focusing on the YouTube Contents Related Reading
A Study on the Using Paratexts for Reading of Children: Focusing on the YouTube Contents Related Reading
This study aims to find a reading method that can apply youtube reading contents for children, treating a new type paratext that appeared in the digital media environment. Through ...
Adapting Middlebrow Taste to Sell Stars, Romance, and Consumption
Adapting Middlebrow Taste to Sell Stars, Romance, and Consumption
Although it began as a local slapdash effort to advertise the independent exchanges in Chicago in 1911, Photoplay became the nation's leading movie fan magazine. At first it copied...
Alamut – ob zgodbi in pripovedi,
Alamut – ob zgodbi in pripovedi,
The reader of Alamut can experience a complete reading experience thorough th e intertwining of reading for pleasure, and deep or critical reading, where in the first reading exper...
VICTORIAN READERS
VICTORIAN READERS
There is, perhaps, no richer archiveof Victorian reading experiences than Victorian literature itself. We know how Maggie Tulliver, child of the rural Midlands in the early years o...
MOSAIC for Multiple-Reward Environments
MOSAIC for Multiple-Reward Environments
Reinforcement learning (RL) can provide a basic framework for autonomous robots to learn to control and maximize future cumulative rewards in complex environments. To achieve high ...

Recent Results

Egon Wellesz: An Opera Composer in 1920s Vienna
Egon Wellesz: An Opera Composer in 1920s Vienna
The music of Egon Wellesz, largely forgotten since his death in 1974, is slowly being rediscovered. The last three years have seen the premiere of his Third Symphony in Vienna (rev...
Some Observations on Religion in Safavid Persia
Some Observations on Religion in Safavid Persia
It is indisputable that the religious history both of the Safavid period and of the two centuries that preceded it remains inadequately explored. There existed in Transoxania and A...
Performance Metrics for State-Based Imitation Learning
Performance Metrics for State-Based Imitation Learning
We propose five new domain-independent metrics for evaluating and comparing performance at imitating a state-based expert. We use two agents in the RoboCup environment to compare t...

Back to Top