Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Targeted metagenomic sequencing with spiked primers for enrichment of viruses in wastewater for pathogen surveillance
View through CrossRef
ABSTRACT
Background
Wastewater surveillance offers an underutilized opportunity to identify high-risk viral pathogens that pose public health risks. Although metagenomic approaches have been increasingly adopted for human wastewater surveillance, little attention has been given to its application in rural agricultural settings. Untargeted metagenomic sequencing of wastewater poses considerable technical challenges for viral detection due to fragmented genomes and low viral abundance. While existing enrichment methods partially address these challenges, high costs and proprietary protocols limit adoption in resource-constrained settings.
Objective
We developed a fully open-source primer design algorithm (
Open MSSPE Design
) and evaluated Metagenomic Sequencing with Spiked Primer Enrichment (MSSPE)
1
, as a practical strategy for metagenomic surveillance of swine slurry and farm wastewater samples collected from rural agricultural settings. This non-invasive MSSPE strategy addresses the challenge of detecting extremely low-abundance viral targets amid samples dominated by a background of bacterial and eukaryotic nucleic acids.
Methodology
We generated fifteen primer sets targeting high-priority DNA and RNA viral pathogens affecting human and animal health in Southeast Asia using our open-source primer design algorithm. Twenty-five wastewater and swine slurry samples from smallholder farms in northern Thailand underwent parallel library preparation—untargeted mNGS and MSSPE—for direct comparison. Libraries were sequenced on Illumina platforms and analyzed using Chan Zuckerberg ID (CZ ID)
2
. Rarefaction analysis assessed performance at sequencing depths of 100,000–1.5 million reads per sample.
Results
We detected multiple high-risk DNA and RNA viruses in wastewater samples from smallholder farm operations. MSSPE achieved substantial viral enrichment across nine pathogenic DNA and RNA viruses, with a median two-fold enrichment of reads per million, with variability across targets (IQR: 1.01–3.44x) and a nearly 10% median increase in breadth of genome coverage (IQR: 4.54–11.84%), while retaining sensitivity for untargeted pathogens. MSSPE also increased the odds of detecting targeted viruses (OR 1.35, CI 1.14–1.60), with the greatest advantage at shallow sequencing depths where MSSPE required fewer reads to identify targeted viral taxa relative to mNGS.
Conclusions
MSSPE demonstrated the ability to enrich shallow-depth sequencing (<2M reads per sample) sufficiently to detect priority viruses without substantially increasing library preparation time or cost. This open-source workflow supports cost-effective metagenomic viral surveillance for resource-constrained settings, providing a non-invasive method for detecting low-abundance viral targets in high-background sample types at rural agricultural interfaces with elevated risk of zoonotic spillover.
Title: Targeted metagenomic sequencing with spiked primers for enrichment of viruses in wastewater for pathogen surveillance
Description:
ABSTRACT
Background
Wastewater surveillance offers an underutilized opportunity to identify high-risk viral pathogens that pose public health risks.
Although metagenomic approaches have been increasingly adopted for human wastewater surveillance, little attention has been given to its application in rural agricultural settings.
Untargeted metagenomic sequencing of wastewater poses considerable technical challenges for viral detection due to fragmented genomes and low viral abundance.
While existing enrichment methods partially address these challenges, high costs and proprietary protocols limit adoption in resource-constrained settings.
Objective
We developed a fully open-source primer design algorithm (
Open MSSPE Design
) and evaluated Metagenomic Sequencing with Spiked Primer Enrichment (MSSPE)
1
, as a practical strategy for metagenomic surveillance of swine slurry and farm wastewater samples collected from rural agricultural settings.
This non-invasive MSSPE strategy addresses the challenge of detecting extremely low-abundance viral targets amid samples dominated by a background of bacterial and eukaryotic nucleic acids.
Methodology
We generated fifteen primer sets targeting high-priority DNA and RNA viral pathogens affecting human and animal health in Southeast Asia using our open-source primer design algorithm.
Twenty-five wastewater and swine slurry samples from smallholder farms in northern Thailand underwent parallel library preparation—untargeted mNGS and MSSPE—for direct comparison.
Libraries were sequenced on Illumina platforms and analyzed using Chan Zuckerberg ID (CZ ID)
2
.
Rarefaction analysis assessed performance at sequencing depths of 100,000–1.
5 million reads per sample.
Results
We detected multiple high-risk DNA and RNA viruses in wastewater samples from smallholder farm operations.
MSSPE achieved substantial viral enrichment across nine pathogenic DNA and RNA viruses, with a median two-fold enrichment of reads per million, with variability across targets (IQR: 1.
01–3.
44x) and a nearly 10% median increase in breadth of genome coverage (IQR: 4.
54–11.
84%), while retaining sensitivity for untargeted pathogens.
MSSPE also increased the odds of detecting targeted viruses (OR 1.
35, CI 1.
14–1.
60), with the greatest advantage at shallow sequencing depths where MSSPE required fewer reads to identify targeted viral taxa relative to mNGS.
Conclusions
MSSPE demonstrated the ability to enrich shallow-depth sequencing (<2M reads per sample) sufficiently to detect priority viruses without substantially increasing library preparation time or cost.
This open-source workflow supports cost-effective metagenomic viral surveillance for resource-constrained settings, providing a non-invasive method for detecting low-abundance viral targets in high-background sample types at rural agricultural interfaces with elevated risk of zoonotic spillover.
Related Results
Metagenomic sequencing of composite airplane wastewater for surveillance of emerging viruses
Metagenomic sequencing of composite airplane wastewater for surveillance of emerging viruses
Abstract
Robust early warning of emerging viruses requires sampling populations that drive spread coupled with assays capable of detecting new viral variants or spe...
Wastewater-based surveillance for tracing the circulation of Dengue and Chikungunya viruses
Wastewater-based surveillance for tracing the circulation of Dengue and Chikungunya viruses
SummaryBackgroundArboviral diseases, transmitted by infected arthropods, pose significant economic and societal threats. Their global distribution and prevalence have increased in ...
DengueSeq: A pan-serotype whole genome amplicon sequencing protocol for dengue virus v1
DengueSeq: A pan-serotype whole genome amplicon sequencing protocol for dengue virus v1
Background Amplicon-based sequencing (PrimalSeq) was developed in response to the Zika virus epidemic due to difficulties generating complete genomes using metagenomic approaches [...
Target-enriched metagenomics-informed qPCR detects rare, potentially dangerous β-lactamase genes in wastewater
Target-enriched metagenomics-informed qPCR detects rare, potentially dangerous β-lactamase genes in wastewater
Abstract
The rapid emergence of novel antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) decreases the effectiveness of empirical antibiotic treatment for pathogen infections. Envi...
Toward Rapid Sequenced-Based Detection and Characterization of Causative Agents of Bacteremia
Toward Rapid Sequenced-Based Detection and Characterization of Causative Agents of Bacteremia
Abstract
Rapid pathogen diagnosis and characterization performed by metagenomic DNA sequencing may permit physicians to better target therapies i...
Identification of clinically relevant multi-drug resistant ESKAPEE isolates from hospital wastewater surveillance in Thailand
Identification of clinically relevant multi-drug resistant ESKAPEE isolates from hospital wastewater surveillance in Thailand
IntroductionWastewater surveillance has recently emerged as a promising method for AMR surveillance, but few studies have directly compared wastewater surveillance samples with cli...
Detection of viruses of public health importance in wastewater samples using conventional PCR techniques and a targeted enrichment whole genome sequencing panel
Detection of viruses of public health importance in wastewater samples using conventional PCR techniques and a targeted enrichment whole genome sequencing panel
Abstract
Wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE) is an effective surveillance approach for monitoring viruses of public health relevance at the community level, complem...
Phylogenomic analysis of Uganda influenza type-A viruses to assess their relatedness to the vaccine strains and other Africa viruses: a molecular epidemiology study
Phylogenomic analysis of Uganda influenza type-A viruses to assess their relatedness to the vaccine strains and other Africa viruses: a molecular epidemiology study
ABSTRACT
Background
Genetic characterisation of circulating influenza viruses is essential for vaccine selection and mitigation...

