Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Divine Command Theory in Early Franciscan Thought: A Response to the Autonomy Objection
View through CrossRef
In recent years, many scholars have bemoaned the gradual demise of traditional virtue ethics, and its eventual replacement in the later Middle Ages by divine command theory. Where virtue ethics nurtures a capacity for spontaneous moral judgement, this theory turns on adherence to ordained duties and laws. Thus, virtue ethicists among others have tended to object to the theory on the grounds that it undermines the role of the moral agent in moral adjudication. In this article, by contrast, I will argue that there is a way of construing divine command theory, which is not susceptible to this critique. To this end, I will turn to the work of first-generation Franciscan scholars, who affirmed the necessity of human understanding of divine commands and the complete freedom of the will to observe them.
Title: Divine Command Theory in Early Franciscan Thought: A Response to the Autonomy Objection
Description:
In recent years, many scholars have bemoaned the gradual demise of traditional virtue ethics, and its eventual replacement in the later Middle Ages by divine command theory.
Where virtue ethics nurtures a capacity for spontaneous moral judgement, this theory turns on adherence to ordained duties and laws.
Thus, virtue ethicists among others have tended to object to the theory on the grounds that it undermines the role of the moral agent in moral adjudication.
In this article, by contrast, I will argue that there is a way of construing divine command theory, which is not susceptible to this critique.
To this end, I will turn to the work of first-generation Franciscan scholars, who affirmed the necessity of human understanding of divine commands and the complete freedom of the will to observe them.
Related Results
Game Theory in Business Ethics: Bad Ideology or Bad Press?
Game Theory in Business Ethics: Bad Ideology or Bad Press?
Solomon’s article and Binmore’s response exemplify a standard exchange between the game theorist and those critical of applying game theory to ethics. The critic of game theory lis...
The exhausted short-timer: Leveraging autonomy to engage in production deviance
The exhausted short-timer: Leveraging autonomy to engage in production deviance
This article explores the conditions under which autonomy may lead to production deviance (unsanctioned, non-task-focused behavior) rather than acting as a motivational job charact...
Malthus, Jesus, and Darwin
Malthus, Jesus, and Darwin
Malthus' theological ideas were most clearly presented in the final two chapters of the first edition (1798) of his Essay on the Principle of Population. They can be classified und...
IN THE TWILIGHT OF DOOYEWEERD’S CORPUS: The Publishing History of In The Twilight of Western Thought and the Future of Dooyeweerd Studies
IN THE TWILIGHT OF DOOYEWEERD’S CORPUS: The Publishing History of In The Twilight of Western Thought and the Future of Dooyeweerd Studies
When it comes to studying the ideas of Herman Dooyeweerd as found in the volume In the Twilight of Western Thought: Studies in the Pretended Autonomy of Philosophical Thought, one ...
Freedom as Satisfaction? A Critique of Frankfurt's Hierarchical Theory of Freedom
Freedom as Satisfaction? A Critique of Frankfurt's Hierarchical Theory of Freedom
Abstract
This article is a critical assessment of Harry Frankfurt's hierarchical theory of freedom. It spells out and distinguishes several different and irreconcila...
Sketches of Autonomy: Capitalist Subsumption and Working-Class Resistance in Alan Sillitoe's Early Fiction
Sketches of Autonomy: Capitalist Subsumption and Working-Class Resistance in Alan Sillitoe's Early Fiction
Alan Sillitoe's Saturday Night and Sunday Morning and “The Loneliness of the Long-Distance Runner” offer a fresh perspective on the endurance of class antagonisms in the Britain of...
Instrumentalism vs. Realism and Social Construction
Instrumentalism vs. Realism and Social Construction
An important debate in the philosophy of science, whether an instrumentalist or realist viewof science correctly characterizes science, is examined in this paper through the lens o...
Religion, Platonist Dialectics, and Pragmatist Analysis: Marcus Tullius Cicero’s Contributions to the Philosophy and Sociology of Divine and Human Knowing
Religion, Platonist Dialectics, and Pragmatist Analysis: Marcus Tullius Cicero’s Contributions to the Philosophy and Sociology of Divine and Human Knowing
Whereas Socrates, Plato, Aristotle and Augustine are probably the best known of the early Western philosophers of religion, Marcus Tullius Cicero (106-43 BCE) also played a particu...
Recent Results
The Via Claudia Nova
The Via Claudia Nova
At the period when, after a process of development extending over almost five centuries, the road-system of ancient Italy had attained to its maturity, we find that Rome was connec...
'Saints without God'
'Saints without God'
This article addresses Camus’s response to Christianity and the problem of suffering in the context of the early twentieth century. Owing to his association with the existentialist...
Aeschylus' Prometheus
Aeschylus' Prometheus
Prometheus Bound (Prometheus Vinctus) is a tragedy of disputed authorship in the Aeschylean corpus, and the only extant Greek drama populated almost entirely by divine beings. The ...
Liberation or purification? Prostitution, women’s movement and nation building in South Korea under US military occupation, 1945–1948
Liberation or purification? Prostitution, women’s movement and nation building in South Korea under US military occupation, 1945–1948
This article investigates postcolonial South Korea’s prostitution policy as a focal point of sexual politics in the undertaking of nation building under US military occupation (194...